Shifting the Lens: From Deficit Discourse to Strengths-Based Approach
Building on the principles of community consultation, engagement, co-creation, and control, strengths-based approaches emphasise the capacities, capabilities, and resources within a community, rather than focusing primarily on its problems or deficits. This approach aligns with Heather McCormack's statement that recognises Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities' diversity, knowledge, and cultural values. In reductive reasoning, the complex web of socio-cultural, economic, and political factors affecting health are often overlooked. This may inadvertently perpetuate harm by not addressing underlying social determinants of health, contributing to a deficit discourse that stigmatises communities as passive recipients of public health interventions.
Embracing Indigenous Resilience and Knowledge
In contrast, a strengths-based approach acknowledges and draws upon the inherent resilience and knowledge within communities. As McCormack highlights, this is particularly relevant in Indigenous health promotion. By respecting the world's oldest living culture, public health interventions can draw upon a rich source of community strength and knowledge. This approach respects Indigenous communities' autonomy, upholds the principle of justice by acknowledging historical injustices, and embodies beneficence by seeking to improve health outcomes through culturally appropriate interventions.
From Consultation to Co-Creation: An Ethical Imperative
Ethically, the distinction between consultation and co-creation becomes even more critical in this context. Merely consulting with communities may not adequately respect their cultural knowledge or utilise their inherent strengths, especially when dealing with diverse Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. Co-creation, however, positions these communities as equal partners, enabling them to fully contribute their unique insights into health challenges and solutions.
The Power of Genuine Community Engagement
Co-creation reflects genuine and thorough community engagement, respecting each community's values and networks as essential factors in planning and implementing public health programs. This approach not only demonstrates respect for culture but also acknowledges the unique position of 'insider' community members to help develop solutions. This empowerment is an embodiment of respect for autonomy and justice, serving to reduce health disparities by fostering community ownership and control over health interventions.
My Key Learning: Honouring Community Knowledge and Values
Reflecting on the content this week, a key learning I have taken from particularly the interviews is the importance of moving beyond consultation to a co-creation model, especially when underpinned by a strengths-based approach. This can lead to more ethically sound and effective public health interventions. This approach honours the knowledge, values, and strengths of communities, particularly of those as culturally rich and diverse as Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. Ethically, it aligns with principles of respect for autonomy, justice, and beneficence, fostering community empowerment and sustainable health outcomes.
Comments